|
Management of public funds must be improved
Custódio Duma, Joaquim Dimbana
Social Watch Mozambique, Mozambican Human Rights League
Although there has been economic growth in Mozambique in the last 10 years, the population’s standard of living remains among the lowest in the world. The country continues to face enormous social, economic and regional gaps, and there are no clear inclusive and participatory public policies. Good governance is an essential requirement to provide the population with a minimum of basic social services and living conditions which can pave the way towards ensuring genuine social security.
|
More
than 60% of the population still depends completely and exclusively on
agriculture for survival. According to a recent Ministry of Agriculture
report (SETSAN, 2005), there are 520,000 people in the south of the country who
are facing a situation of extreme food insecurity and need immediate assistance.
The number could rise to 660,000 if no help is forthcoming before October 2007.
In the south, the production of cereals has fallen by around 30% and vegetables
by 12%. The southern and central regions are ravaged by cyclones, floods and
drought.
Meanwhile, the report Poverty and well-being in Mozambique (2004)
reveals that rates of poverty in different regions of the country vary widely.
The highest rates are in the central region (around 74%), and in the provinces
of Sofala (87.9%), Tete (82.3%) and Inhambane (82.6%), but these areas are not
very densely populated and only 28.2% of the poor live in them. In contrast,
39.3% of the nation’s poor live in the much more densely populated provinces
of Nampula and Zambezia, but although poverty rates are higher in these two
regions the annual budget allocation they receive is less than the funds that go
to other less impoverished provinces with smaller populations.
TABLE 1. Measures of the incidence and depth of poverty (using the basic
basket approach)
|
|
Incidence of poverty
|
Depth of poverty
|
|
1996-1997
|
2002-2003
|
Difference
|
1996-1997
|
2002-2003
|
Difference
|
|
National
|
69.4
|
63.2
|
-6.2
|
29.3
|
25.8
|
-3.5
|
|
Urban
|
62.0
|
61.3
|
-0.7
|
26.7
|
26.2
|
-0.5
|
|
Rural
|
71.3
|
64.1
|
-7.2
|
29.9
|
25.6
|
-4.3
|
|
North
|
66.3
|
68.1
|
1.8
|
26.6
|
27.7
|
1.1
|
|
Centre
|
73.8
|
59.2
|
-14.6
|
32.7
|
23.5
|
-9.2
|
|
South
|
65.8
|
63.6
|
-2.2
|
26.8
|
27.1
|
0.3
|
|
Niassa
|
70.6
|
61.2
|
-9.4
|
30.1
|
21.8
|
-8.3
|
|
Cabo Delgado
|
57.4
|
72.3
|
14.9
|
19.8
|
28.1
|
8.3
|
|
Nampula
|
68.9
|
68.1
|
-0.8
|
28.6
|
29.1
|
0.5
|
|
Zambezia
|
68.1
|
58.6
|
-9.5
|
26.0
|
21.1
|
-4.9
|
|
Tete
|
82.3
|
71.6
|
-10.7
|
39.0
|
34.2
|
-4.8
|
|
Manica
|
62.6
|
60.2
|
-2.4
|
24.2
|
26.3
|
2.1
|
|
Sofala
|
87.9
|
48.4
|
-39.5
|
49.2
|
16.6
|
-32.6
|
|
Inhambane
|
82.6
|
80.1
|
-2.5
|
38.6
|
41.3
|
2.7
|
|
Gaza
|
64.6
|
58.6
|
-6.0
|
23.0
|
19.7
|
-3.3
|
|
Maputo Province
|
65.6
|
66.9
|
1.3
|
27.8
|
28.9
|
1.1
|
|
City of Maputo
|
47.8
|
45.5
|
-2.3
|
16.5
|
16.2
|
-0.3
|
Source:
Poverty and well-being in Mozambique (2004).
According to the report cited above, only 12% of rural dwellers have access to
running water and only 31% have an indoor latrine, whereas in urban areas the
percentages are 66% and 68% respectively. A mere 20% of the rural population
have a health care centre or post in their village. This is probably the reason
why some 60% of childbirths in rural areas take place in the home, while in the
cities the rate is 16%.
According to the Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS), life
expectancy in Mozambique is just 41.9 years, among the lowest in Africa, and the
HIV/AIDS pandemic is partly responsible for this situation.
Government plans to promote development
Official projections indicate that the country’s economy will grow by 7% in
2007, and there will be one-digit inflation. Investment will be mainly
concentrated on improving and harnessing infrastructure in the sectors of
energy, communications and water supply in rural and peri-urban areas.
The current government has made the fight against poverty the main priority
in its five-year plan. This is seen as a precondition for human, economic and
social development not only in the countryside but also in the cities. There are
huge differences between rural and urban areas and between the regions near
Maputo and those farthest away, and these gaps are a long way from being
rectified. The administrative unit in the country’s 11 provinces is the
district, and the idea is to use each district as a nucleus for national
development. One of the most important elements in the five-year plan is the
allocation of MZN 7 million (USD 274,000) to each of the 128 districts, to be
used initially for public investment programmes.
In 2006, Social Watch Mozambique criticized this policy, alleging that the
distribution of funds did not follow coherent allocation criteria nor was it
proportional to the potential or the needs of each district. The project was a
failure in terms of management, implementation and monitoring, which led the
government to decide that the funds would be disbursed as credits or
micro-credits to finance initiatives from local development organizations and
associations. This connected state activity with the commercial bankers, in
spite of the fact that it is a consultative committee run by the local
administration that decides which organizations to finance.
The Mozambique school network will be expanded in 2007. There are expected to be
4.9 million pupils in the general education system (covering grades 1 through
10), which represents a 12% increase over the 2006 figure, and there are plans
to build 1,425 classrooms throughout the country. This amounts to significant
progress, but there are still serious problems as regards the distribution of
school resources. The province of Zambezia, for example, has an enormous
population but receives the lowest education allocation from the national
budget.
There are also plans to build seven hospitals in rural areas, plus three health
care centres and four medicine storage facilities, and to renovate another 17
medical facilities (hospitals and health care centres). In 2007 work will begin
on the construction of a general hospital in Matola, training centres in Mocímboa
da Praia in Cabo Delgado and Cuamba in Niassa, and the Infulene Institute of
Health Sciences in Maputo. In addition, antiretroviral treatment will be
extended to cover more than 96,000 people living with HIV/AIDS. It is estimated
that around 1.8 million people in Mozambique are HIV-positive.
Foreign assistance
Overall government expenditure in 2007 is expected to be MZN 70.8 billion (USD
2.77 billion), and around 54% of this will come from foreign sources.
The World Bank promised USD 70 million in 2007 to support the government’s
programme to combat extreme poverty with the Social Economic Plan, and this sum
came into the country’s general state budget in the form of a credit. The
government made a commitment to use these funds to reduce poverty levels and
promote rapid economic growth that would be sustainable and inclusive, but it
did not give any concrete data about the plan. The USD 70 million was to be
handed over in two payments, one in each six-month period. A World Bank
representative said that the poverty reduction assistance programme included a
new series of credits whose main objective was to support the implementation of
the Action Plan to Reduce Absolute Poverty 2006-2009 (PARPA II). This will
include three annual operations to be implemented between 2007 and 2009. The
programme began in 2004, and the country received the sum of USD 60 million in
that year.
In July 2007, the United States awarded Mozambique a five-year grant totalling
USD 506.9 million, to be invested in reducing poverty rates in the country. The
government has decided to invest these funds in the provinces in the northern
region.
In Mozambique the financial sector is very weak because of high levels of
corruption, a lack of transparency and access to information, fraud in the
banking system, and the fact that the legal apparatus does not have the
independence to tackle financial wrongdoing.
Failures in governance erode the people’s trust
Poverty in the country is generally defined as serious deficiencies in the areas
of nutrition, health, schooling, access to potable water, and a safe and healthy
living environment, which are all critically important for individual
well-being. Therefore, poverty is seen as an evil that must be attacked by
implementing public policies geared to individual and social well-being.
This definition of poverty suggests that the government should implement public
policies that are not just designed to improve the country’s economic
development indicators but are aimed at improving people’s lives. Every day
there are reports that large numbers of people are dying for lack of medical
attention or medicines, and in the district of Chibabava in Sofala province
there are many who have nothing but wild fruit to live on. The government went
so far as to finance the purchase of donkeys at some administrative posts in the
north of the country to help move sick people, and at the hospital in the city
of Nampula there is a three-month waiting list for medical consultations.
Citizens’ participation versus bureaucracy and centralization
Under pressure from donors, the government of Mozambique set up a mechanism
known as the ‘joint review’ whereby each year the government itself, the
donors and representatives from civil society review current economic and social
plans by examining the balance of what has been achieved. This mechanism should
be transparent and honest, but it is becoming more and more complicated and
centralized because the flow of information is rather slow and the data that is
supposed to be discussed, compared and monitored by those taking part is not
received in good time.
In the joint review this year it was suggested that the problem was not that the
government lacked the resources to improve the lives of the people, but that it
lacked suitable public policies and the political will and ability to manage
public funds. For example, in 2006 the Ministry of Justice received a mere USD
100,000 to reform the prison system, while a permanent secretary in the province
of Sofala spent around USD 325,000 from the public treasury to buy and renovate
a house for himself. This fact is on the record, documented in the accounts of
the Administrative Tribunal.
It is this kind of mismanagement of public funds and poor rationalization of
resources, plus the fact that state agents accused of corruption and
appropriating public funds for their own ends are not brought to trial, that
constitute the main obstacle to reducing poverty in Mozambique.
The wrong choices
In 2007 the government announced that it was giving priority to the ‘green
revolution’, a programme whereby subsistence-level peasant farmers would be
transformed into traders. However, this scheme overlooked the fact that
agricultural techniques in the country are rudimentary and there is no incentive
to modernize them. Something similar happened last year, when the government
promoted the cultivation of jatropha to produce biofuel as an alternative to
petrol, which was becoming more and more expensive. Vast areas of land were
allocated to this crop, but today its future is unclear because there was no
defined policy as to how this product was to be produced and exploited, and
already people are talking about the negative and polluting effects this plant
can have.
Mozambique is a member of the Southern African Development Community (SADC), and
starting in 2008 various consumer products will be exempt from 20% of customs
duties under the trade protocol in this regional agreement. Business leaders in
the country are predicting disastrous results from this tariff change because
they are not in a situation to compete with a strong economy like that of
neighbouring South Africa.
Citizenship without security
The people of Mozambique are further and further away from being able to
exercise their economic rights or enjoy the benefits of economic justice. It has
been calculated that half the population is not officially registered, which
means that these individuals cannot prove that they are citizens for any
official purposes. One of the main reasons why enrolment rates in schools are so
low is that many children are unregistered and do not have any kind of personal
documentation or identity card.
Crime rates are increasing, mainly in the big urban areas, and according to the
newspaper Jornal Domingo more than a
thousand people were murdered last year alone. In 2006, a study by the
Mozambique Human Rights League found that 69% of the young people involved in
crime and prostitution in the cities of Beira and Maputo had resorted to these
activities for lack of work, food or housing. This suggests that good health
care and education have a direct impact on well-being, because they improve
quality of life and the ability to participate in society, just as good health
and education increase an individual’s ability to be economically productive.
The current government is increasingly losing credibility and the people’s
trust because it has failed to put a stop to rising crime, and nor can it bring
corruption under control or punish the guilty. Public policies are not bringing
about any improvement in the quality of life of the population; some people are
taking the law into their own hands and lynching suspected criminals, while
others are turning to violence to satisfy their basic needs. Essentially, the
Mozambican people do not feel they are involved in any kind of human development
process.
References
National Directorate of Planning
and Budget, Ministry of Planning and Finance, Economic Research Bureau, Ministry
of Planning and Finance, International Food Policy Research Institute Purdue
University (2004). Poverty
and well-being in Mozambique: the second national assessment. [online]
<www.sarpn.org.za/documents/d0000777/index.php>.
SETSAN (Technical Secretariat for Food Security and Nutrition) (2005).
Monitoring report on food and nutritional security in Mozambique. Maputo:
SETSAN, Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries.
|